Instructions for Judges: Please evaluate each article based on the following criteria. Score each category from 1 (Poor) to 5 (Excellent), considering the bullet points provided. Add any qualitative comments that support your score. Remember that judging is anonymous; evaluate only the article content.
1. Originality & Insight (Score: 1-5)
- Ideas fresh and engaging?
- Unique perspective or angle?
- Insightful analysis provided?
- Avoids clichés and predictability?
- Demonstrates creative thinking?
2. Clarity & Conciseness (Score: 1-5)
- Language clear and precise?
- Easy to understand main points?
- Sentences well-constructed?
- Free of unnecessary jargon or ambiguity?
- Concise writing style (avoids wordiness)?
3. Research & Evidence (If Applicable) (Score: 1-5)
- Sufficient supporting evidence used?
- Sources credible and relevant?
- Evidence effectively integrated?
- Proper citation used ([MLA Style])?
- Demonstrates understanding of topic?
4. Argument & Logic (If Applicable) (Score: 1-5)
- Clear central argument or thesis?
- Logical flow of reasoning?
- Argument well-supported by evidence?
- Persuasive and coherent points?
- Addresses complexity/counterpoints (if relevant)?
5. Structure & Organization (Score: 1-5)
- Engaging introduction?
- Logical paragraph development?
- Smooth transitions between ideas?
- Effective overall structure (beginning, middle, end)?
- Satisfying conclusion?
6. Impact & Engagement (Score: 1-5)
- Holds the reader’s attention?
- Thought-provoking or emotionally resonant?
- Memorable content or message?
- Appropriate tone maintained?
- Leaves a distinct impression?
7. Grammar & Mechanics (Score: 1-5)
- Correct grammar and sentence structure?
- Accurate spelling?
- Proper punctuation?
- Overall proofreading quality (few/no typos)?
- Readability unhindered by errors?
8. Adherence to Rules (Score: 1-5)
Within word count (800-2500)? Was the correct file format used? Correct font/spacing/margins used? No identifying author info within the file?
Overall Score: [Sum of Scores or Weighted Score] / [Total Possible Score]
Judge’s Comments: [Space for qualitative feedback, strengths, weaknesses, overall impression]
Note on Weighting: The organizers may assign specific percentage weights to each criterion before final scores are calculated (e.g., Originality 20%, Clarity 15%, etc.). Ensure you are aware of any weighting scheme. Sources and related content